Heat or Cold Therapy for Muscle Pain, Which One Is The Best?

Medically reviewed by | By

Update Date 29/11/2019 . 3 mins read
Share now

Muscle pain or myalgia can be due to various causes such as muscle tension, overuse, or injury. Aside from adequate rest and over the counter pain reliever, heat or cold therapy can be an effective, safe and affordable home intervention. Knowing when and how to apply each method appropriately can help relieve your symptoms and prevent further complications.

Heat therapy for muscle pain

heat therapy

Mechanism of action: By helping your muscles to relax, heat can alleviate both pain and stiffness. It also encourages circulation and blood flow to the affected area. This help to get rid of lactic acid buildup that contributes to pain. Non-inflammatory muscle pain such as due to overexertion, muscle cramps and spasms may respond well to heat therapy. It is also useful at managing stiff, sore joints affected by arthritis.2

Method: Heat therapy can be applied using a heating pad, heated paraffin wax treatment, hot bath, hot shower or heat wrap to your sore area. Heat therapy works best by exposure for a period of time. 15 to 20 minutes of heat therapy can help relieve minor stiffness or tension. Moderate to severe pain can benefit from longer sessions of heat therapy like a warm bath, lasting between 30 minutes and two hours.3

Caution: Be careful not to burn yourself using heat therapy. Do not use heating cream along with a heating pad, and never leave the pad for too long. In case of inflammation as bruise or swollen, opt for cold therapy instead.

Cold therapy for muscle pain

cold therapy

Mechanism of action: Cold therapy reduces blood flow to the affected area, alleviating painful swelling and reduce inflammation. It also slows down the signal of pain from your nerves to your brain and has a numbing effect on the affected area. This can be helpful for fresh injuries.2 When tissue is physically damaged, inflammation will occur for a few days. This can be seen as skin that is sensitive to touch and is hot, red and swelling. Arthritis flare-up, for example, may suit more with cold therapy than heat therapy. Heat therapy can be counterproductive in this condition.

Method: Cold therapy can be applied through the cold tub, homemade ice pack or a bag of frozen vegetables, chemical cold pack or a cold washcloth. Do not apply the frozen item directly to the skin, rather wrap it in a towel. Limit its usage for short periods of time, several times a day. Elevate the affected area for best results.4

Caution: Those with sensory disorders such as diabetic individuals should not use cold therapy at home as they may not be able to feel if they overdo it. Cold therapy should not be used on stiff muscles or joints and if you have poor circulation. Be careful to limit your skin’s exposure to no longer than 10 to 30 minutes. Be cautious of hives or skin that turns purple, a sign that you’ve iced for too long.

Which one is the best?

Both heat and cold therapy can be useful when applied properly and are both cheap, easy, and mostly safe. If you’re trying to decide between cold therapy or heat therapy, consider the type of pain you have and where it is, what your doctor recommends, and what relief you personally get from each one.5

For example, if you are suffering from a muscle injury, it may be best to use cold therapy to reduce the inflammation for the first few days, followed by heat therapy to relieve pain. If you are suffering from arthritis, heat therapy can be useful with joint stiffness while cold therapy works best for swelling and acute pain. According to the Arthritis Foundation, either heat or cold may help with pain from arthritis.

The efficiency of both was also reported to be equal. In a randomised controlled trial comparing heat or cold packs for neck and back strain, the participants are given 400mg of ibuprofen orally and then the patients were given half an hour of either a heating pad or a cold pack.

The researchers concluded both heat and cold resulted in mild yet similar improvement in the pain severity. Adding either two of the method to ibuprofen therapy did not change the result. They recommend that the choice of heat or cold therapy should be based on your personal choice.

But even if most muscle aches can be relieved with home treatment, systemic muscle pain throughout your body may indicate an underlying medical condition that requires immediate attention. Consult your doctor if the pain is severe, does not subside after a few days or there is an accompanying symptom such as rash, tick bite, redness, swelling or fever.

Hello Health Group does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.

Read also:

    Was this article helpful for you ?
    happy unhappy"

    You might also like

    5 Gentle Stretches to Melt Away Morning Stiffness

    Whether you have arthritis or general joint pain and stiffness in the morning, gentle stretches may help to kick start your day. Evidence shows that exercise and stretching help to increase blood flow and oxygen ...

    Medically reviewed by Panel Perubatan Hello Doktor
    Written by Helma Hassan
    Fitness, Healthy Living 28/02/2019 . 3 mins read

    Your Gut Bacteria Might Be The Cause of Your Joint Pain

    Inflammation of the joint or arthritis can be presented in many different forms. The most common of them are osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis, both are synonym with joint pain. Osteoarthritis, often referred ...

    Medically reviewed by Panel Perubatan Hello Doktor
    Written by Helma Hassan
    Sponsored
    gut bacteria
    Nutrition, Healthy Living 18/02/2019 . 3 mins read

    Acupuncture May Reduce Muscle Cramps

    The practice of acupuncture is believed to be originated from the mainland of China. In earlier ages, sharpened stones and long sharp bones were used instead of what we are using today, the needles. Acupuncture ...

    Medically reviewed by Hello Doktor Medical Panel
    Written by Muhammad Wa'iz
    Health Tips, Healthy Living 12/02/2019 . 3 mins read

    10 Ways to Get Rid of Inflammation and Joint Pain

    According to the Global Burden of Disease Study in 2010, musculoskeletal conditions (related to muscles, bones and joints) were the second highest contributor to global disability. Researchers estimate that a 60-year-old ...

    Medically reviewed by Panel Perubatan Hello Doktor
    Written by Helma Hassan
    Health Tips, Healthy Living 11/02/2019 . 5 mins read

    Recommended for you

    neurologist migraine

    5 Reasons Why You Should See a Neurologist for Migraines

    Written by Aaron Joseph Sta Maria
    Published on 07/04/2020 . 4 mins read
    How to Relax Your Muscles After Yoga

    How to Relax Your Muscles After Yoga

    Medically reviewed by Panel Perubatan Hello Doktor
    Written by Tran Pham
    Published on 08/12/2019 . 3 mins read
    sleep

    Does Your Sleep Position Worsen Your Back Pain?

    Medically reviewed by Hello Doktor Medical Panel
    Written by Helma Hassan
    Published on 06/03/2019 . 4 mins read
    tempat kerja

    Stiff Neck at the Office? 7 Tips to Adjust Your Workstation

    Medically reviewed by Hello Doktor Medical Panel
    Written by Muhammad Wa'iz
    Published on 04/03/2019 . 3 mins read